Scrap the warp drive: New test shows neutrinos not faster than light

This article has been updated to correct the location of the Gran Sasso laboratory.

It looks like warp speed, time travel and other cool stuff from science fiction are still fiction, after all.

A new experiment at the Gran Sasso laboratory in Italy has found that neutrinos don’t travel faster than light, refuting the results of an experiment in September that seemed to find that they did.

The earlier experiment by the Oscillation Project with Emulsion-Racking Apparatus (OPERA) team at Gran Sasso set the physics world on its ear, because the results seemed to disprove Albert Einstein’s assertion in his Special Theory of Relativity — the foundation of a lot of what we know about the universe — that nothing could travel faster than the speed of light.


Related coverage:

Einstein was wrong? Fire up the Falcon!

Einstein still right: CERN cites flaw in neutrino experiment


The new experiment, from the competing Imaging Cosmic and Rare Underground Signals (ICARUS) team, duplicated the OPERA tests but with different detectors and found that neutrinos travel at light speed, but not faster. “The result is compatible with the simultaneous arrival of all events with equal speed, the one of light,” the scientists said in posting their results.

Both experiments involved shooting subatomic neutrino particles 454 miles from CERN in Switzerland to Gran Sasso in Italy. In Opera’s experiment, the neutrinos arrived 60 nanoseconds sooner than light.

Some physicists immediately expressed skepticism at the results, which in physics terms was like hearing that the sun doesn’t rise in the East, and the OPERA team also said the results had to be verified. In February, scientists said that had found equipment flaws — a loose fiber optic cable and a problem with an oscillator providing GPS time stamps — in the OPERA experiment that could have thrown off the results.

The ICARUS experiment duplicated OPERA’s effort but used a different detector, the Liquid Argon Time Projection Chamber, “a novel detector which allows an accurate reconstruction of the neutrino interactions,” Carlo Rubbia, a Nobel Prize winner and spokesperson for ICARUS, said in a statement issued by CERN.

"ICARUS measures the neutrino's velocity to be no faster than the speed of light,” Rubbia said.

With the new results out, physicists are breathing a sigh of relief. Sandro Centro, another spokesman for ICARUS, told the BBC he, like other physicists, had been skeptical of the OPERA results.

"I didn't trust the result right from the beginning — the way it was produced, the way it was managed," he told the BBC. "I think they were a little bit in a hurry to publish something that was astonishing, and at the end of the day it was a wrong measurement."

So scientists are happy that the universe is what they thought it was, even if science fiction fans might be disappointed that things like intergalactic travel, which would require faster-than-light speed to be feasible, are once again out of reach.

Assuming, of course, that the ICARUS results hold up. Indications are that they will, although CERN Research Director Sergio Bertolucci said in CERN’s statement that “it is important to be rigorous” and that more experiments will be held in May “to give us the final verdict.”

Bertolucci also gave credit to the OPERA team for behaving “with perfect scientific integrity in opening their measurement to broad scrutiny, and inviting independent measurements.

“This,” he said, “is how science works.”

About the Author

Kevin McCaney is editor of Defense Systems. Follow him on Twitter: @KevinMcCaney.

Reader Comments

Mon, Mar 19, 2012 DEFENDER OF THE FREE WORLD

Pons & Fleischman all over again?

Fri, Mar 16, 2012 Paul rever florida

So, my comments from a few months ago, when the claim was made about finding particles that move faster than light, were correct. I stated it was likely there was a measuring error of the equipment being used to measure the speed of the particles. If something with mass moves at the speed of light, it will lose its mass and become light. The mass will be burned off, all that will be left is the light. Theoretically, it is possible to move faster than light, but will never be proven in our lifetimes. Until we can study black holes directly, we will not be able to fins things moving faster than the speed of light. But that theory too is not provable now. Theoretically, objects within a black hole are moving faster than the speed of light because light can not escape the black hole. So, that explains what happens to all the "stuff" that goes into a black hole. It is turned into light due to the immense speed objects are sped up to. The mass of the objects that is "burned off" is what is emitted somewhere in space. Reconfigured back into its pure form. So that is what black holes are..effectively, space recyclers of matter. But this is all just theoretical.

Fri, Mar 16, 2012

Are you kidding me? If you are going to announce to the world that the basic laws of physics are flawed you had better do your homework. The fact that they made this mistake is beyond comprehension but to release the information to press before it was completely proven? WOW!

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above