Both sides should win in public safety network battle
First responders need a dedicated spectrum, but they also need industry's deep pockets
- By William Jackson
- Sep 24, 2010
A battle is developing over a choice swath of radio frequency real estate that is coveted by the nation’s public safety agencies and commercial networking companies. The nation could be best served by accommodating both sides of this battle.
At issue is the role, if any, commercial networks will have in the D Block of the 700 MHz band that has been earmarked for a national public safety network.
The Federal Communications Commission has recommended, and industry supports, licensing the spectrum for broadband commercial networks, with the understanding that public safety agencies would have priority access during emergencies. Fire, police and other safety agencies want a dedicated D Block.
“We’ve got to be able to control our own destiny,” San Jose Police Chief Robert Davis told the Senate Commerce, Science and Technology Committee last week.
Forget the money: Congress should allocate radio frequency band for public safety
Obama to double spectrum available for broadband development
But an analysis by technology consultants Roberson and Associates found that government does not need exclusive access. “Our study concludes that licensing the 700 MHz D Block space for commercial use is the best way to achieve the goal of having a nationwide, interoperable public safety network,” Roberson CTO Ken Zdunek told the committee.
The Roberson study was done for T-Mobile USA, one of the companies that would like to have a piece of the spectrum, so Zdunek might not have been an entirely uninterested witness.
A bill has been introduced in the Senate that would allocate the D Block for public safety while allowing some commercial access, but what the network finally would look like still is far from certain. This battle should be settled soon so the parties involved can get on with building an interoperable network that can provide broadband data and video capabilities to first responders, and it would make good sense to take full advantage of the innovation and deep pockets that commercial networks can provide.
The public-safety community has a legitimate point in asking for dedicated spectrum. It needs a robust network that will be available in emergencies and, just as importantly, one that will be available to first responders without having to compete with the public for bandwidth. And it must be available everywhere, not just where it is economically viable. Proponents point out that the interests of private industry are not those of public agencies. Companies have obligations to shareholders and customers, and must make a profit.
On the other hand, private companies have billions to spend upgrading and expanding their networks and they introduce new services and equipment at a rate that government cannot match. There is a lot to be said for giving public safety agencies access to these resources rather than relegating them to a dedicated government network that could become a ghetto of expensive, outdated technology.
A look at the nation’s highways, bridges and subway systems will tell you that while government can be good at starting projects, it has a poor record of maintaining and upgrading infrastructure. Political pressures on budgets can be as devastating as business considerations. It is one thing to get politicians to appropriate money for a new project; it is quite another to get them to approve money for maintaining an existing system.
Public safety does require dedicated bandwidth, and 10 MHz of spectrum in the 700 MHz band has been set aside for that use. The D Block should be able to provide the additional capacity needed in emergencies while supporting commercial services if it is properly managed. The challenges to this are not technical.
The FCC offered industry a bad deal when the D Block originally went up for auction in 2008, and as a result the spectrum went begging, delaying the public safety network. An agreement should be crafted well before the spectrum is allocated that secures the needs of the public safety community while making good business sense to industry.