Is CEO's honesty about Galaxy Tab and iPad 2 really the best policy?

Samsung chief throws his product under the bus

Back before I got married, people would often ask me what I was searching for in a prospective mate. I would always answer “honesty” as the first criteria I looked for, which often earned me quite a few snickers from my friends. I mean, how do you rate another person based on an honesty scale? And what’s with my obsession with honesty anyway?

Well, being a tech reviewer, I seem to be subjected to quite a lot of dishonesty actually. Marketing people want to put their best foot forward, so they will attempt to dazzle me and the rest of the lab staff with tales about how great their devices are. And if we didn’t put them through extensive testing in the lab, we might never know the truth. In a way, it might be simpler to just be up front with reviewers, or even customers. But that almost never happens. Still, actual lies are pretty rare. Mostly its just a fact of life that marketing people are paid to put their best foot forward.

So it was with great interest when Samsung Electronics CEO Lee Dong-Joo admitted to a Korean news agency that the company’s much-hyped Galaxy Tab 10.1 Android tablet is “inadequate” compared to the new iPad 2 from Apple. Really? When was the last time you heard about a CEO throwing their flagship product under the bus?

Specifically, he says that Samsung’s new 10-inch tablet, which is set to debut this month, is too thick compared to the iPad. He also questions the wisdom of pricing the 10-inch tablet higher than the current Samsung 7-inch model, which was released late last year.

Lots could happen with this story. Perhaps the 10-inch tablet will be delayed while Samsung engineers work to shave off inches. Or perhaps they will simply compensate by selling it for a really low price. That sets up the odd situation where the new model with the larger screen could actually be bought for less than the older Galaxy with a smaller display. And of course, it would need to be priced significantly less than the iPad 2. I don’t see how it could come out with even a similar price at this point. Samsung is likely going to take a bath on the 10.1 if they want to be even moderately successful in terms of sales.

I’ll reserve judgment on the Galaxy for now, but I have to wonder what Lee Dong-Joo was thinking. It’s not about lying, but some confidence in your product would be good. He could have stressed the reasons why the Galaxy Tab 10.1 was better or different than the iPad 2. There are some factors that come to mind right away like the ability to use Flash, the ability to run multiple applications at the same time and the open-source nature of the Android OS. That would be less about lying and more about showing why your product is different than others on the market.

Sure, reviewers like us might have pummeled it on weight and price compared to the iPad 2, but we would have looked at its good points as well. More so than with the reviewer community, now the public will think the Galaxy 10.1 is inadequate compared to the iPad 2, the one thing they will probably remember from this whole affair. Even now, when you Google the Galaxy, you get more news stories about how the CEO doesn’t like his own product than anything else. The only thing worse would be if someone filmed him checking his mail on an iPad over lunch.

Samsung has had a little trouble keeping someone in the top spot in recent years, and I have to wonder if Lee Dong-Joo might suddenly “retire to pursue other interests” after this. Honesty is all well and good, but sometimes, a little razzle-dazzle isn’t bad either.

About the Author

John Breeden II is a freelance technology writer for GCN.

Reader Comments

Thu, Mar 17, 2011

I think saying the product is "inadequate" and that they will have to re think about pricing this new device might give people planning to buy the ipad 2 2nd thoughts and wait for this product to go on sale. for all we know the remark is deliberate to give the company more time to convince people to get this device instead.

Thu, Mar 17, 2011 Art New York, NY

I wonder at your comment that Android is open source. It is my understanding that it's open for the vendor to close in whatever way they choose. I was looking at Android phones and in the end, didn't buy one (yet) because there's a Verizon Android and an ATT Android and a Sprint Android, etc., and none of them let me do whatever I want. I am guessing that the Galaxy's Android and other tablet Androids are going to be the same.

Tue, Mar 15, 2011 DLF

Seems to me Samsung gets a lot of free publicity from their CEO's comment and a way to get consumer reaction to obvious differences between the Tab and the iPad2. If Samsung released the Tab without this remark, everybody would jump all over its size and price compared to the iPad. Now, if/when Samsung release it, all the bad publicity about size and weight is so yesterday's news that people will likely focus on the Tab's strong points. The "remark" could well of been a marketing ploy.

Tue, Mar 15, 2011

I find it odd that the leader of a test and assurance lab is concerned about a CEO that throws his product under the bus. I find it oddly refreshing to find someone in industry that can admit they made a mistake on a product, challenge their people, by doing so, to come up with a better product, and take responsibility before a bunch of people are fleeced and unhappy. Yes, Flash, is an issue with the iPads, but hardly the end of the world, or a distinguishing enough difference to rate other tablets as superior to the iPads and price points are a big issue.

Tue, Mar 15, 2011

I think Samsung's CEO is to be praised. Honesty and Integrity before profits. It seems the tech media has come to the end of the road on honesty. Let us look at M$ Vista. Tell me, how many honest reviews did you read until it got into the mass market and the puiblic had been fleeced? One las note; Hey Stevey, cna you read that on your iPhone or do you have it in a "death grip?"

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above