Police in patrol car talk on radio

3 reasons smartphones aren't ready to replace police radios

San Luis Obispo County Sheriff Ian Parkinson says the California county’s new hybrid cellular and RF communications system is superior to its stand-alone land mobile radio network. Enabled by a digital dispatch platform from Raytheon and Twisted Pair, it leverages commercial cellular service to extend the police network to just about any smartphone.

More Info

Mixing smartphones, radios gives new life to dispatch system

Replacing an end-of-life radio dispatch system with an IP platform linking smartphones with traditional radios extends the reach and the functionality for San Luis Obispo County's first responders. Read more.

But this system is a supplement to, not a replacement for, police radios. For the most part, land mobile radios do one thing: They let policemen talk with other policemen and firefighters talk with other firefighters. With the economical functionality of ubiquitous smartphones, why not do away with those expensive legacy radio systems completely?

There are a number of reasons why smartphones and cellular carriers are not ready to replace public safety radio networks. Three of them:

1. Bandwidth:  Commercial carrier networks are consumer systems and are not dedicated to public safety use. This means first responders have to compete with consumers for bandwidth, which is likely to be at a premium during an emergency when police, firefighters and other safety personnel need it most. FirstNet, a nationwide public safety network now in the works, would be dedicated to first responders and built to more robust standards of reliability and availability, but that project is years away from completion.

2. Planned obsolescence: “Cell phones now are semi-disposable,” said Parkinson. They are upgraded and replaced every few years, and departments relying on them would have to ensure that applications and infrastructure supporting their use would continue to support new models and versions.

3. Durability: Most smartphones also are not ruggedized. “We have to be concerned whether they will be dropped,” Parkinson said, because they are not built for police and rescue work. They also do not have the battery life needed to be in use constantly through a 10- or 12-hour shift, which is one of the features of land mobile radio handsets.

Police radios are expensive and they only do one thing, but they do it well, Parkinson said. “Portable radios are costly because they are ruggedized and have that battery life.”

About the Author

William Jackson is freelance writer and the author of the CyberEye blog.

Reader Comments

Fri, Feb 21, 2014

I am a security professional and have been for 18 years and my current employer uses Sprint's PTT (push to talk) phones and a "public safety style of dispatching". I have been petitioning to switch from the PTT phones to radios because the two devices are built with two different purposes. Phones have lots of contacts for phone numbers, addresses, etc. When I am dealing with an emergency with 10 or more personnel and I need to switch to a different talk group - a sprint PTT version of changing a channel on a radio, I have to scroll through different names on the list in order to find who I want to need to talk to. On a radio, I simply move the knob from channel #1 to #4 or #6 etc. If the phone manufacturers would create a way to switch talk groups by a knob function, then they may be a worth a look - until then, phones should only be used to Supplement - not replace the radio....sometimes the best technology is the tried and true technology

Mon, Aug 19, 2013 Rik Rasmussen Durham, NC

This articles fails to mention the primary issue, in my opinion, and that is the "one to many" aspect of Public Safety dispatch. I have yet to see a cellular type service demonstrate the ability to perform that function well.

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above