Supreme Court ponders electronic archiving lawsuit

Supreme Court ponders electronic archiving lawsuit

By Christopher J. Dorobek

GCN Staff

FEB. 10—The Supreme Court could decide by Feb. 18 whether to hear a case concerning agencies' handling of electronic records and whether they can delete electronic records as long as they have made copies in some format.

Public Citizen, a Washington public interest group, filed a petition in November asking the high court to reverse a lower-court ruling that lets agencies continue to use the National Archives and Records Administration's rule, General Records Schedule-20. Public Citizen has characterized that rule as tantamount to letting agencies print and delete important electronic records.

The Justice Department's Office of the Solicitor General last week filed a curtly worded, 26-page response to Public Citizen's complaint, arguing that Public Citizen has shown a 'persistent misunderstanding of what GRS-20 does.'

'GRS-20 does not authorize the deletion of records from the agency's electronic or other record-keeping systems. Nor does it address the separate question of what kind of record-keeping system agencies should have,' the Justice response states.

GRS-20 simply lets agencies delete records from their existing systems once those records have been moved to 'an agency record-keeping system that preserves each record's content, structure and context,' the brief states.

GRS-20 has been at the heart of a controversy since 1996, when Public Citizen first filed its lawsuit.

NARA late last year issued a guidance urging agencies to continue making plans for handling electronic records, although it did not set a deadline. In the Dec. 28 bulletin, archivist John W. Carlin said NARA is in the midst of a 'comprehensive review of the policies and processes for the scheduling and appraising of federal records.'

A copy of the NARA bulletin is available at

inside gcn

  • network

    6 growing threats to network security

Reader Comments

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group