Stop and think before launching NMCI

I urge the Navy and Congress to stop the Navy-Marine Corps Intranet from being implemented.

NMCI's goal is to privatize the service's computer communications services. Basically, we give a contractor our current computers and network, and the contractor rents it back to us at more than our current operating costs'a good deal for the contractor, but a waste of taxpayers' money.

I am a member of the Naval Aviation Systems Command team and find it wasteful that I will pay more than twice the current seat price to get the same services I already have.

In an NMCI report to Congress dated June 30, NAVAIR claimed a per-seat cost of $2,873. The same report's preferred alternative is $5,800 per seat.

There is no tangible or intangible benefit in the report in favor of implementing NMCI at NAVAIR or throughout the Navy and Marine Corps. It is a waste of taxpayer money.

Maybe parts of the service can use some help to become more computer efficient, but don't penalize the whole Navy. Solve the specific problem.

Using a Navy automobile analogy, if the car had a flat tire, the NMCI solution would be to replace the car, not fix the flat.

Most of the people I know work to become more efficient. We embrace improvements, but NMCI is a step in the wrong direction.

I'm amazed that a lowly GS-12 must point out to everyone that the emperor has no clothes. Perhaps if Navy brass had done a business case analysis first we would not be starting down the wasteful NMCI path.

Name withheld

GCN welcomes letters to the editor. Letters must include name, address, telephone number and signature of the author. Send to: Letters to the Editor, Government Computer News, 8601 Georgia Ave., Suite 300, Silver Spring, Md. 20910. Or you can send them via e-mail to editor@gcn.com.

Stay Connected

Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.