Now what?

GROWING EA: Vendors expand offerings

As enterprise architectures take hold across government, EA vendors are evolving and expanding their product lines, in effect broadening their EA workspaces.

Last year two major vendors of EA software were purchased by larger companies. Both companies now use EA technology as part of broader offerings.

Troux Technologies Inc. of Austin, Texas, acquired Computas Technology Inc. and its Metis line of modeling software. Similarly, Telelogic AB of Malmo, Sweden, acquired Popkin Software Inc. of New York and its System Architect EA tool.

Prior to the Popkin purchase, Telelogic was perhaps best known for its DOORS requirements management software, which can generate specifications from an architecture. DOORS is popular with complex-platform builders, including those in aerospace and defense.

'System Architect and DOORS were highly paired in the government,' said Jan Popkin, former head of Popkin and now chief strategist for Telelogic. The company also offers software for project visualization and decision support.

By yoking with the Popkin software, all the applications can be enhanced with broader enterprise views, Popkin said. Likewise, the Telelogic tools expand the reach of Popkin to specific applications. This will allow architects and system planners to work more closely together.

An agency upgrading a set of applications could use Telelogic's collection of tools to build the desired platform using an architecture built in System Architect. From there, the agency could build a request for proposals through DOORS, Popkin said.

Troux has similar plans for Metis, though that company operates in a slightly different field: IT governance software. Troux's software manages IT inventory data, allowing architects and system managers to evaluate current capabilities, plan for new growth and verify standards compliance.

Computas' customers are now making fuller use of their EAs, said Pat Motola, president of Troux. They are seeking a greater level of detail through analysis of models and getting the resulting information in front of more users. 'Think of it as taking a specific set of the analytics and packaging them around a specific high-value problem area,' Motola said. 'Once you have EA information, what are the big problems you can apply it to?'

Troux's platform includes a workflow engine, portal and data repository, which allow users to easily move EA data into other operational areas.

For instance, most agencies do portfolio management, tracking the many applications across an agency. The EA can provide a high-level overview of these operations, allowing agencies to pick out redundant or outdated apps. EAs could also help agencies refine their service management models, Motola said. A service can range from e-mail to payroll, and may come with some concrete metrics such as required uptime and service costs.

The Office of Management and Budget's Service Reference Model shows how to define services at an abstract business level. The CIO's office can use Troux' Services Portfolio Management software to attach specific services to the reference model.

'This really is an extension of EA, carrying it in the direction that OMB wants to take it,' said Bill Wright, Troux's chief technology officer.

Even OMB is offering tools to help agencies make more of their EAs. To help agencies to start thinking along these lines, the office released an assessment framework that shows how EAs could be used in decision-making and in aligning IT with mission objectives (find it at,

Said Michael Farber, vice president of consulting company Booz Allen Hamilton Inc. of McLean, Va., 'That framework is what agencies use to help gauge their progress and set the stage for their future work.'

BIG PICTURE: The Interior Department's Colleen Coggins is using the agency's enterprise architecture to improve performance; Interior has posted its EA on the Web.

Rick Steele

Integration with the other management disciplines is the issue everyone is trying to grapple with now.'

' Mike Dunham, Thomas and Herbert Consulting LLC

Four years into the enterprise architecture initiative, agencies have blueprints in place. It's time to put those EAs to work.

Colleen Coggins, chief architect for the Interior Department, is proud of her agency's enterprise architecture. Take a look, she urges, it's on the Web.

Anyone using a browser capable of rendering Scalable Vector Graphics, a format for viewing Extensible Markup Language-based image files, can view Interior's EA at There are links from abstract strategic goals, such as providing recreational resources, to such specifics as which Interior offices support which missions and what metrics are used to gauge their success. (Can't see anything in your browser? Adobe makes a popular SVG viewer; get it at,

As impressive as Interior's Enterprise Architecture Repository may be to browse, the true value of the EA, according to Coggins, is how it benefits the agency. Using the IT blueprint, Interior's CIO office has identified for retirement more than 100 redundant systems.

'The whole purpose of our program is to improve mission performance for each of our business areas,' Coggins said. 'It is about analyzing the business and the IT to make holistic recommendations.'

Last month, the Office of Management and Budget released its latest outline detailing how agencies should use their federal enterprise architectures for the budget-planning process. Richard Burk, chief architect of OMB's Office of E-Government and Information Technology, urged agencies to find ways of using EAs to save money and improve performance.

But for many agencies, taking the EA off the proverbial shelf and incorporating it into daily activities remains a challenge, albeit a necessary one.

'The only way you gain efficiencies with your enterprise architecture is to use it,' said Rick Thomas, CIO of the Army Community and Family Support Center, which develops and maintains leisure activities for troops worldwide. 'That is one of the biggest gaps right now in the EA world. How do you put the EA to use?'

Here are three ways an agency can leverage a fully functional enterprise architecture:

1. Get on the same page as operations. One of the biggest challenges agency CIOs face today is getting more involved with the agency's operational offices, said Mike Dunham, former senior enterprise architect for the Treasury Department and chief enterprise architect at IT consulting firm Thomas and Herbert Consulting LLC of Silver Spring, Md.

A program manager with a smooth-running operation might not want to bother with the extra work of complying with policies from the CIO's office. But if the CIO's office is to oversee the agency's IT systems, then this reluctance can be a problem.

EAs can facilitate communications between the two parties, Dunham said. A CIO office can offer its EA prowess to help wring some greater efficiency from systems or undertake a necessary but complicated upgrade, such as moving to IPv6. It can also be applied to other management initiatives, such as efforts to merge EA with the capital planning and investment control processes.

'Integration with the other management disciplines is the issue everyone is trying to grapple with now,' Dunham said.
This technique can even be used across different agencies. Appealing to program managers' stake in their systems' well-being was certainly a factor in the success of the Air Force's Space Situation Awareness Integration Office, which developed a cross-agency enterprise architecture detailing the space resources of 12 agencies.

The National Security Space Office uses the Air Force's EA for its own national planning and guidance documents, such as the National Security Space Plan and National Security Space Program.

In order to get a clear picture of the government's total assets, representatives from the NSSO meet with individual program managers to find out what resources they have'and what they can use from other agencies, according to Lt. Col. Bruce Cessna, deputy director of the office.

'We sit across the table with their subject matter experts to identify what systems, sensors or data products they have available if they are a provider, or what requirements or data they need,' Cessna said.

By working with the equipment owners, the office has been able to create a cross-agency enterprise architecture that describes the country's space assets. Their work can, in turn, be used by the participants.

The office generates models using the Joint Capability Integration and Development System standards for reporting requirements in a uniform fashion, and the Department of Defense Architecture Framework. By complying with JCIDS and DODAF, other agencies can use the models for their own projects, enabling even more cross-agency collaboration.

2. Create applications and procure systems. While the average EA may be too abstract to actually use as a template for a new software program, it can provide guidance for the developer. This is what the General Services Administration is demonstrating with its Open Source eGov Reference Architec-ture. The GSA's CIO office has assembled a software suite to generate application templates directly from its enterprise architecture.

'What we are trying to do is make business models more useful,' said George Thomas, GSA's chief architect.
The goal of OSERA is to 'maintain explicit traceability from higher- to lower-level architecture abstractions, such that business and logical models can be used to generate code required by various run-time platforms,' Thomas said.

Through GSA's enterprise architecture, OSERA can be used to create a business model which, in turn, can be used to generate a logical software model that defines functional roles as services.

'We are able to structure the code base and minimize manual implementation required,' Thomas said in an e-mail. 'Implementers are ... given requirements specifications that are aligned with business drivers and existing services across the enterprise.'

This spring, the team hopes to offer a distributed object-based model that would run on the JBoss open-source application server using Business Process Execution Language. The team uses modeling plug-ins for the Eclipse integrated development environment to create a set of service definitions.

But CIO offices shouldn't limit themselves to single applications. EAs can also provide the basis for procuring new hardware and complete systems. When the Army Community and Family Support Center wants to contract work for a new project, it hands the EAs over to the winning bidder.

This ensures that both the contractor and the agency have a clear definition of the deliverable, the Army's Rick Thomas said.

Unfortunately, some vendor education might be necessary. Many vendors do not know EA, he said. He recalls giving one large government IT vendor a complete set of EA documentation for a project, only to have the company request a meeting to define the requirements.

'It is very frustrating when you spend a lot of time, energy and money doing it the right way and turn it over to one of the vendors who have not bothered to keep up to speed,' Thomas said.

But as vendors grow more hip to EA, agencies will be able to communicate their system requirements more directly. And agreeing on a terminology has benefits beyond system procurement.

3. Communicate in one language. EA also can help get all IT workers speaking the same language'no small feat for an agency as large as the Army. The Army's Network Enterprise Technology Command uses its EA as a way of standardizing network operations center terminology, said Rodrigo 'Rod' Trevino, government lead for the Army Enterprise Network Operations Inte- grated Architecture project.

'EA brings together the strategic and the tactical as one network we can manage. We didn't have that before,' Trevino said.

Netcom is now building an EA for its portion of the Defense Department's Global Information Grid, dubbed LandWarNet. The project is about 70 percent complete. The office is approaching the project in a modular fashion, by defining individual capabilities.

Many descriptions of individual capabilities are finished, such as IP Transport Management, Computer Platform Management, Enterprise Security Management, Enterprise Support, and Enterprise Services and Applications Management.

With these definitions in place, Netcom will have a standard language to describe capabilities, both for its own personnel and those of other services that also use the GIG. Two units may use different network management tools, for instance, but they can tell each other how the services operate. A specialist transferred to another center could easily pick up operations there.

Messages could also be communicated up the chain of command in a consistent fashion, according to Joe Walker, technical lead for supporting contractor SRA International Inc. of Fairfax, Va.

The Army Community and Family Support Center also uses its EA to help officers understand how the command works. Thomas' office creates a one-page flowchart that summarizes the overall EA. It makes, at a glance, the center's mission easy to understand.

'In one page, you could look at the whole process and see where everything relates,' Thomas said.


  • Records management: Look beyond the NARA mandates

    Pandemic tests electronic records management

    Between the rush enable more virtual collaboration, stalled digitization of archived records and managing records that reside in datasets, records management executives are sorting through new challenges.

  • boy learning at home (Travelpixs/

    Tucson’s community wireless bridges the digital divide

    The city built cell sites at government-owned facilities such as fire departments and libraries that were already connected to Tucson’s existing fiber backbone.

Stay Connected