Could jailbreak rule speed government iPhone adoption?

Lack of access to apps is a key hurdle

You can now use non-Apple programs on your iPhone without fearing copyright recriminations.

Colloquially known as “jailbreaking,” the practice had received heated resistance from Apple, which said it infringed on its copyrights by using modified versions of its operating system, encouraged piracy and taxed the company’s customer support staff. Proponents said they simply wanted to have access to features and programs on their phones that Apple had limited or restricted.

Librarian of Congress James Billington issued the new rule Monday, under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. The ruling is actually broader than Apple – it applies to any smart phone operating system that prevents the installation of outside applications.

By law, Billington is required to review the DMCA every three years to see if there are any emerging technologies that might be exempt from the law's ban on circumventing access to copyrighted material. This time, there were 19 cases the public had submitted, and Billington exempted six. The iPhone ruling, as well as some other technology exemptions, came at the request of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a consumer advocacy group.

Related stories:

There's gonna be a jailbreak

The summer of my Droid

The ruling may open the door for more government users of iPhones, which has a low adoption rate in the public sector. One of the major drawbacks to government adoption had been Apple’s restriction on the applications that could run on the phone.  However, "jailbreaking" isn't something Apple supports or wants to encourage, Dan Schointuch at MoneyTalks News, provides a primer on just how to do it, but also warns that it is likely to void the phone's warranty and possibly violate the wireless service agreement.

Billington also ruled that users can “unlock” their phones, or lift the controls that restrict the phone’s use to one particular wireless carrier.

Among the other technologies Billington exempted: The use of copyrighted movie excerpts incorporated into new works for criticism or comment in colleges and universities, documentary filmmaking, and noncommercial video; and literary works in e-book format that contain access controls preventing the book’s read-aloud function or that render the text in a specialized format.

The companies involved have not commented on the decision.

About the Author

Kathleen Hickey is a freelance writer for GCN.

inside gcn

  • data architecture (Quardia/

    AI adoption: Don't ignore the fundamentals

Reader Comments

Thu, Jul 29, 2010 Rob B.

Why does everyone ignore the emission security threat of a device whose battery cannot be removed? "Airplane" mode is not an approved method of disabling a smart phone. The iPhone isn't going to see adoption by government until that is fixed. The issue applies to companies who do classified government work or are fearful of industrial espionage, as well. Any security policy would have to require tampered phones be confiscated and the user disciplined (if it's a government issued device).

Thu, Jul 29, 2010 Dave

Re: the ruling allowing users to unlock their phone to use it with another carrier. If I have a GSM phone, can I use it on a CDMA or EV-DO network, or vice versa?

Wed, Jul 28, 2010

Why break the phone when you can buy software that allows the iPhone to break into your corporate intranet and you can use many of your applications thatway. See for something that says "Files2Phones - Enterprise Edition is the management solution, the Access Server is installed securely inside the corporate firewall, enabling corporate Apple iPhone users to access their desktop data or applications inside the network from anywhere, at anytime, in real time through the VPN feature of the iPhone." Don't know if it really works, but it is liberating and scary.

Wed, Jul 28, 2010 Michael

@Peter, My iPod used to be Jailbroken from Blackra1n. when iOS4.0 came out, it was jailbroken by redsn0w. both jailbreaks however did not make it so I could steal anyone's data. Jailbreaking an iPod is not really what everyone thinks it is, it is not a hack or anything that makes it so you can somehow now see what other people are doing. And there are no apps on Cydia or Rock (Jailbroken App Stores) that gives you the ability to do so.

Wed, Jul 28, 2010 A Fed

The jailbreaking being referenced in the article is that the fed wants to run their own apps on the iPhone. There are many law enforcement apps that components under DOJ would like to have running on a smart phone. Other agencies have home grown apps that they would like to see accessible by smart phone.

Show All Comments

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group