Wind power blows military in different directions

Whether it's good or bad depends on the circumstances

The military is harnessing wind to generate power at the same time that troublesome discoveries about the effects of wind turbines on radar are putting military services in conflict with clean-energy efforts.

The Army's Communications-Electronics Research, Development and Engineering Center sees wind power as a key component of future portable power. CERDEC officials wrote on the "Armed With Science" blog at, that as a follow-up to its Rucksack Enhanced Portable Power System effort, "CERDEC Army Power envisions the next generation of photovoltaic systems to use wind power generation as part of a hybrid system for larger-power demand applications. We call it the Reusing Existing Natural Wind and Solar system, or RENEWS."

RENEWS would combine wind generation and solar power to collect and store energy in a bank of batteries, according to the blog post. The battery banks would have power outlets to allow soldiers and other personnel to plug devices in to use power or charge their own batteries.

"RENEWS falls into this category of higher power production," the post continues. "Once fully developed, the system is designed for two-man lift that provides higher levels of power and energy storage for use with communications and surveillance in a forward-based environment, where vehicular and/or utility-grid power is not always available."

CERDEC is based at Fort Monmouth, N.J. Across the country, in the Mojave Desert, plans to build even more wind turbines have met with resistance from the military, who say the towers interfere with radar.

"Moving turbine blades can be indistinguishable from airplanes on many radar systems, and they can even cause blackout zones in which planes disappear from radar entirely," wrote Leora Broydo Vestel in the New York Times. "Clusters of wind turbines, which can reach as high as 400 feet, look very similar to storm activity on weather radar, making it harder for air traffic controllers to give accurate weather information to pilots."

According to Vestel's article, when a local developer told Navy and Air Force officials that he was planning to install just three turbines, one each at three industrial locations near an area under military control, the armed forces opposed the project.

"The military says that the thousands of existing turbines in the gusty Tehachapi Mountains, to the west of the R-2508 military complex in the Mojave Desert, have already limited its abilities to test airborne radar used for target detection in F/A-18s and other aircraft," Vestel reported.

Gary Seifert, who has been studying the radar/wind energy clash at the Idaho National Laboratory, an Energy Department research facility, described the situation as a potential train wreck involving "the competing resources for two national needs: energy security and national security.”

About the Author

Technology journalist Michael Hardy is a former FCW editor.

inside gcn

  • When cybersecurity capabilities are paid for, but untapped

Reader Comments

Wed, Jan 4, 2012 Florence In awe of that asnwer! Really cool!

In awe of that asnwer! Really cool!

Fri, Nov 25, 2011 Lefty Touchdown! That's a rellay cool way of putting it!

Touchdown! That's a rellay cool way of putting it!

Fri, Sep 3, 2010

The type of turbines that would be used for mobile units in an FOB environment would not be as high and can be limited to be under 100'. It has been found that once turbines reach 100' or higher that they may cause interference with radar and even that is questionable at times. The idea of building hybrid systems should be to be continued and should be tested as they will save countless of lives.

Mon, Aug 30, 2010

Given that wind turbines are sprouting world-wide, including in areas where the USAF and USN may be flying missions, it sounds like they need to ramp up their R&D to accomodate it. Banning turbines from anywhere near their test areas so as to not confuse the tests, means the tests will not reflect the real-world conditions the radars systems may need to operate in.

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group