Md. prisons: Job applicants don't have to supply Facebook passwords (for now)
State ACLU chapter cheers 45-day suspension, alleges privacy infringements
- By Alice Lipowicz
- Feb 23, 2011
Maryland prison authorities have temporarily suspended their policy of requiring prospective and current employees to provide their Facebook passwords and login information after a complaint from the Maryland chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union.
The Maryland Department of Public Safety and Correctional Services notified the ACLU on Feb. 22 that the policy has been suspended for 45 days in light of privacy concerns the group raised.
Maryland Public Safety Secretary Gary Maynard said the policy was instituted to help identify job applicants and prison workers seeking recertification who may have affiliations with illegal gang activity.
How to stop Facebook friends from tracking you
National Guard Bureau tells what not to write on Facebook
“The department’s efforts to explore an applicant’s behavior on social media networks stems not from a desire to invade personal privacy but rather from a legitimate and serious concern with the infiltration of gangs in our prisons,” Maynard wrote to the ACLU branch Feb. 22.
“This is a newly emerging area of the law, and in light of that, I agree that we must be convinced of the practice’s utility as well as be mindful of the path we are taking,” Maynard wrote.
The ACLU initially notified Maynard on Jan. 25 of concerns about the experience of corrections supply officer Robert Collins, who was ordered to supply his Facebook login information during a recertification interview. Collins was told at the time that the request was based on departmental policy and applied to all new applicants and recertifications, said Meredith Curtis, an ACLU-Maryland spokeswoman.
“While the ACLU appreciates the DOC’s need to ensure that corrections applicants and employees are not engaged in illegal activities, the demand for an officer’s personal Facebook password simply goes too far,” Deborah Jeon, legal director for the ACLU of Maryland, said in a statement. “It is equivalent to a demand that officers permit the government to listen in on their personal telephone calls as a condition of employment.”
In April of 2010, Collins took personal leave of absence from his job with the state's corrections department after three years of employment. When applying for recertification in November to return to work, he was asked for the Facebook user name and password and was told it was a standard requirement, the ACLU Maryland branch said.
“I understood the investigator to be saying that I had no choice but to hand over my Facebook login and password if I wanted to continue my employment with the division of corrections,” Collins said in a statement released by the ACLU Maryland branch.
The ACLU's Maryland branch believes that the practice is illegal under the Federal Stored Communications Act and under Maryland laws that prohibit access to stored electronic communications without valid authorization, Curtis said. The prison department’s policy also would have allowed inappropriate access to Facebook postings of friends of the applicants or of the corrections workers seeking recertification, Curtis added.
No other agencies in Maryland are reporting similar practices, Curtis said.
“We are certainly glad the policy has been suspended, and we will be watching closely and we’re willing to work with them to ensure the policy protects their privacy and the privacy of their Facebook friends,” Curtis said.
Alice Lipowicz is a staff writer covering government 2.0, homeland security and other IT policies for Federal Computer Week.