Banning e-mail in the office: Is this a good idea?

People have complained for years about having to live with e-mail, but can you live without it?

The CEO of Europe’s biggest IT services company plans to find out, announcing a plan to ban e-mail for his company’s 74,000 employees, who are located in 42 countries.

Thierry Breton, a former French finance minister and CEO of the France-based Atos, says that only 10 percent of the e-mail his employees get is worthwhile, and he wants them to stop using it within 18 months, according to the Telegraph.

Instead, he wants them to communicate face to face, by phone, or via text messaging or Facebook-style interfaces.

Few would argue with e-mail’s downsides. In 2009, 94 percent of all e-mail was spam. That percentage has dropped as fraudsters and other attackers find other vectors, but spam still makes up about 74 percent of e-mail traffic. And even if an organization uses an aggressive spam filter, people still get inundated with “corporate spam,” in the form of inconsequential interoffice e-mails.

Nicolas Moinet, information and communication professor at Poitiers University, described the problem like this: "We have now reached crazy situations where employees go to a meeting, continue to send e-mails and then ask colleagues present to send them an e-mail to know what was said during that meeting," the Telegraph reported.

But is doing away with e-mail entirely the solution? Texting and social media platforms can be faster and in many ways easier. And the upcoming generation that will be going to work in a few years already largely do without e-mail. But are there some things e-mail still does that the other formats don’t.

Breton points out that only 11 percent of 11-to-19-year-olds use e-mail, deeming social media more useful. All those 11-to-19-year-olds working in your office no doubt agree, but are there some things e-mail does that texting and internal social media platforms don’t? Can you send a PDF via text? Do you want to post it on a social media platform? Or are bicycle messengers about to come back into vogue?

Breton says most time spent on e-mail is wasted, and he’s right. But are Facebook or internal social media apps better? A platform such as Yammer, which allows internal communications in a Facebook-like format, does have some distinct advantages for intra-office communications, but, like any other form of communication, also has the potential to become too much of a water cooler.

Derek Thompson of The Atlantic lays out the advantages of doing away with e-mail, but ultimately concludes that, “Facebook messaging and Gchats can be as much of a time-suck as e-mail. It's not about the technology. It's about the users.”

And maybe it’s about the medium, too. Social media will likely replace many of the functions e-mail is used for today, and for the better. But can e-mail be killed entirely? Or will it, like postal mail, find itself downgraded but still useful?

Could your office function without e-mail? Let us know in the comments section below.

About the Author

Kevin McCaney is a former editor of Defense Systems and GCN.


  • Records management: Look beyond the NARA mandates

    Pandemic tests electronic records management

    Between the rush enable more virtual collaboration, stalled digitization of archived records and managing records that reside in datasets, records management executives are sorting through new challenges.

  • boy learning at home (Travelpixs/

    Tucson’s community wireless bridges the digital divide

    The city built cell sites at government-owned facilities such as fire departments and libraries that were already connected to Tucson’s existing fiber backbone.

Stay Connected