website analysis

Federal websites must step up their game, study concludes

Although citizens increasingly go online for government information and services, the federal websites that facilitate this interaction aren’t up to the job, according to a new study from the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation.

The study looked at variables like speed, security and accessibility for the disabled in its analysis of almost 300 federal websites.

“Despite years of progress in digital government, a striking number of federal websites do not even meet many of the U.S. government’s own requirements, let alone private-sector best practices,” Alan McQuinn, ITIF research analyst and the report’s lead author, said in the report’s announcement. “It is incumbent upon the new administration, supported by Congress, to make websites more convenient, accessible and secure.”

The majority of websites -- 78 percent -- passed the speed test for desktop sites, but far fewer -- 36 percent -- passed mobile speed tests.

The researchers looked at encryption and domain name security when evaluating the sites’ security status. They found that 61 percent of websites sufficiently implemented both tools.

A majority of the tested websites were accessible to people with disabilities, but 42 percent failed the tests because of issues including insufficient contrast for people with sight disabilities and pages that could not be read using screen reader technology.

A panel of industry experts and the report authors discussed the study’s findings at the March 8 announcement. One idea they drilled in on was consolidating websites across agencies.

Chris Neff, the vice president of marketing at NIC, said the patchwork quilt of government websites can be confusing for citizens who are looking for services that involve more than one agency. It can be scary, he said, to combine multiple branches of government into one site, but some places have already begun to do it., for example, is bringing services from multiple agencies into one location, he said.

Panelists said the Trump administration can build on the Obama administration’s efforts to consolidate websites so there are fewer domains offering the same amount of information.

Analytics will also play a role in improving websites, according to John Landwehr, vice president and public sector CTO at Adobe. Federal agencies should determine where people are going on their sites and make it easy for them to get to those popular pages. Site visitors who begin filling out a form but leave the page before finishing is another indication of a problem, Landwehr said.

The improvement of government websites must begin with executive leadership that institutes timelines, expectations and penalties if improvements are not made, Neff said.

“It is incumbent upon the new administration, supported by Congress, to build upon previous efforts to modernize federal websites, pushing them to be more convenient, accessible, and secure,” the study concludes. “These efforts will only come to fruition by identifying problems, creating a plan to address them, and promoting a transparent system for website metrics that pushes the government to constantly improve itself.”

Read the full study here.

About the Author

Matt Leonard is a former reporter for GCN.


  • Records management: Look beyond the NARA mandates

    Pandemic tests electronic records management

    Between the rush enable more virtual collaboration, stalled digitization of archived records and managing records that reside in datasets, records management executives are sorting through new challenges.

  • boy learning at home (Travelpixs/

    Tucson’s community wireless bridges the digital divide

    The city built cell sites at government-owned facilities such as fire departments and libraries that were already connected to Tucson’s existing fiber backbone.

Stay Connected