Emerging Tech

Blog archive
Gesture controlled computer

Gesture control: Great innovation or Tower of Babel?

The companies at CES this year seemed to be really focused on display technology, including actually showing some working OLED models. But beyond just the physical nature of the displays, the industry also seems to be obsessed with making sure we can communicate with our displays in innovative ways.

I’ve already predicted that the proliferation of Windows 8 is going to spike a demand for touch screens, even at the desktop level. But according to the companies at CES, everything from televisions and phones to cars and games are going to begin adding gesture technology.

We have a request in to test one of the first Leap Motion devices when they become available in a couple of months, since many Leap-enhanced devices could start making their way into public-sector circles. But there are many companies introducing gesture interfaces, or soon will be.

Something I hadn’t considered, though, was brought up by Computerworld editors after sampling gesture-controlled devices at CES. There are no standards. Going from one gesture-based input device to another now could be as different as speaking French or Chinese. Motions that do one thing for a specific device might do nothing at all with another, or worse, do something different that what you desire. Want to move a file from one folder to another? Sorry, you just formatted the hard drive with your left arm.

The problem is that some companies -- and I’m looking at you, Apple  -- have tried to copyright a lot of gestures, such as pinching to zoom in or out of a screen (though U.S. patent authorities recently rejected  that one, at least temporarily), or sliding to unlock a device.

The online site io9 points out that a whole lot of gestures are already copyrighted,  and not just by Apple. That company seems to be the biggest gesture hoarder, even applying for copyrights on crazy three-fingered, twirling gesticulations that probably won’t ever be used, but which it doesn't want anyone else getting their grubby three fingers on. In a way it reminds me of the early days of the Web, when all the good, short addresses were being snapped up quickly.

Faced with the elimination of the more common gestures, companies have to get creative to make their new devices work while not stepping on the legal toes of someone else.

If we don’t want to be issued a hula hoop and jump rope in order to flip through our TV channels in the future — and really, nobody wants that — I suggest that the industry get together and form a gestures working group, like the IEEE has for wireless, to develop standards that everyone could use.

Gesture controls really could be a huge change in how people user their computers, whether at home, in the office or in the field. It’s easy to see how it could catch on in presentations or educational settings, as well as with mobile, and even desktop, devices. And it has potential in medical settings, such as operating rooms, where not having to touch a screen or keyboard is an advantage. But gestures would have to work in a uniform manner, like a mouse or touchpad does.

That would mean some companies would need to give up their patents on gestures for the good of the whole. The alternative is a gesture war that could stifle what could be one of the most innovative areas to hit computing in years. And if that happens, I can only think of one appropriate gesture as my response.

Posted by John Breeden II on Jan 15, 2013 at 9:39 AM

inside gcn

  • urban air mobility (NASA)

    NASA seeks partners for urban air mobility challenge

Reader Comments

Wed, Apr 3, 2013 earth

Well this is a simple problem. The Leap should be able to support the use of ASL or some other language for the deaf. And that should not be copyrightable or patentable. So why reinvent the whell (sic).
Also I think it would be quite useful for the deaf if other folks learned a sign language. Though their secret communication channel wouldn’t be so secret anymore. I expect they will go through life with a bit less frustration.

Wed, Jan 23, 2013

I don't get the idea of copyrighting a gesture. Can you copyright words used as a command?

Wed, Jan 16, 2013 Jim Van Damme

This could lead to recognition of sign language. ASL interpreters get paid $50-100 an hour.

Wed, Jan 16, 2013 Cowboy Joe

We been down this road before - anybody remember "Graffiti" on a PalmPilot?

Wed, Jan 16, 2013 Bill Nolte

Touch screen and gesture-based input can be difficult to impossible for disabled individuals. I hope that any such technologies allow an easy escape mechanism.

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above


HTML - No Current Item Deck
  • Transforming Constituent Services with Business Process Management
  • Improving Performance in Hybrid Clouds
  • Data Center Consolidation & Energy Efficiency in Federal Facilities

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group