FBI official calls for alternate Internet to secure critical systems

The United States needs an alternate, transparent, restricted Internet if it is to secure the critical systems that handle such things as utilities and financial transactions, an FBI official says.

Shawn Henry, the bureau’s executive assistant director, speaking at the International Systems Security Association conference recently, said the increasing numbers of cyber threats continue to outpace efforts to defend critical computer systems. These efforts are further hampered by the anonymity of the Internet.

“We can't tech our way out of the cyber threat," Henry said, according to the Associated Press. "The challenge with the Internet is you don't know who's launching the attack."

Earlier this month, the Government Accountability Office released a report stating that information security incidents at 24 federal agencies have increased 650 percent during the past five years due to a combination of more numerous threats and persistent shortcomings in security controls, GCN reported.

Having an alternate Internet accessible only by known, trusted parties, with no anonymity, would greatly improve defense efforts, said Henry, who called cyber threats one of the "most serious threats" facing the nation, reported eWeek

Henry called the Internet "arguably the greatest invention" but at the same time an "incredibly dangerous place," eWeek reported. He also advocated taking highly sensitive information completely offline.

Henry is not the only FBI official calling for a separate, more secure network, nor is the FBI the first to mention such an option. At the May Federal Computer Week Federal Executive Briefing on risk mitigation, Steven Chabinsky, deputy assistant director of the FBI’s Cyber Division, also called for an alternate network with greater visibility and less privacy, GCN reported

“There is no such thing as safe and secure cloud computing because there is no such thing as safe and secure computing,” he said. Chabinsky stopped short of suggesting a separate Internet or proposing a specific architecture.

And people file-sharing information pirates, upset that a group such as WikiLeaks can lose its Web hosting company after running afoul of authorities, have talked about building their own alternate Internet registry, New Scientist reported.

Reader Comments

Thu, Nov 10, 2011 Amnon Victoria BC CANADA

USCIIIIII CODE is the solution for universal telemetries of personal-voiceprint and Natural-logic automation capabilities The FBI can develop for the WwWwW the www, w3 and alike can not master.

Wed, Nov 9, 2011 Roy Rogers Eden Prairie, MN

Old Indian saying: Only the government can cut the top off a blanket, sew it to the bottom, and call it a longer blanket.

Thu, Oct 27, 2011

Get rid of all the "paper tigers" who work for the Government (see obama for example) and hire folks with real world experience. Thats how you get these things done without having to hire additional hoards of people. The government answer is ALWAYS "we need more money, we need more people"

Thu, Oct 27, 2011

We had a secure Internet solution until the brain surgons in Washington decided to make it a gift to the World! It was called ARPANET, remember?

Tue, Oct 25, 2011 Any-mouse

I wanted to add Duh after my first response but I didn't want to insult any of the enforcement folks. They are forced into a hoard of work because of the structure of the internet. It just seems ridiculous to me how all those involved in Comm have put up with an infrastructure that is as attack prone as it is. There has been an entire industry created to attempt to circumvent vulnerabilities. To perpetuate it is incredible.

Show All Comments

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above